Honoring Neither the Letter nor the Law
8-03-2014, 23:33

Font size: [ A+ ] / [ A- ]

 

In 1994, Ukraine and Russian made a deal: Nukes for sovereignty. Moscow took Kiev’s 1,900 nuclear weapons. Now, 20 years later, it wants to take its sovereignty.

 

 

 

Against the backdrop of the crisis caused by Russia's military occupation of Crimea, Tuesday's flight-test of a Topol intercontinental ballistic missile (ICBM) was, to say the least, badly timed.

 

 

It also served as a good reminder that Ukraine, not so long ago, had the world's third largest fleet of ICBMs -- as well as the third largest nuclear arsenal. In 1994, Kiev agreed to hand over its nuclear stockpile to Russia for dismantlement in return for certain commitments, including to respect the former Soviet state's sovereignty. This agreement became known as the Budapest Memorandum of Security Assurances. And today, Moscow's actions in Crimea are in flagrant violation of those commitments.

 

 

When the Soviet Union collapsed in 1991, Ukraine housed 130 SS-19 ICBMs -- each capable of carrying six nuclear warheads -- in underground silos. A single SS-19 warhead had an estimated nuclear yield more than 20 times that of the bomb that leveled Hiroshima in 1945. In addition, 46 SS-24 ICBMs, individually capable of carrying 10 nuclear warheads, were deployed in central Ukraine, giving the country a total of 176 ICBMs. The newly independent country also inherited 44 Tu-95 Bear-H and Tu-160 Blackjack strategic bombers, as well as hundreds of Kh-55 nuclear air-launched cruise missiles to arm those aircraft.

 

Immediately upon its split from the Soviet Union in 1991, Ukraine had 1,900 strategic nuclear warheads -- a larger arsenal than those of Britain, France, and China combined.

Immediately upon its split from the Soviet Union in 1991, Ukraine had 1,900 strategic nuclear warheads -- a larger arsenal than those of Britain, France, and China combined.

 

In 1992, Kiev agreed to dismantle its strategic delivery systems, transfer the nuclear warheads to Russia for elimination, and accede to the Nuclear Non-Proliferation Treaty as a non-nuclear weapon state. The Ukrainians insisted, however, on certain conditions, including compensation, assistance for eliminating missiles and bombers, and security assurances. U.S. diplomats worked with their Ukrainian and Russian counterparts to broker a trilateral statement, signed by U.S. President Bill Clinton, Ukrainian President Leonid Kravchuk, and Russian President Boris Yeltsin in January 1994. It specified the commitments that the United States and Russia would undertake to address Ukraine's conditions.

 

 

The Ukrainian government attached particular importance to three concerns. First, Kiev insisted on compensation for the commercial value of the highly-enriched uranium in the nuclear warheads. Thus, the statement ensured that Russia would provide Ukraine with the equivalent amount of low-enriched uranium in fuel rods for the country's nuclear power plants, which generated 50 percent of Ukraine's electricity at the time.

 

 

Second, Ukraine lacked the resources to dismantle the missiles, bombers, and missile silos on its territory. The United States agreed to provide the Nunn-Lugar Cooperative Threat Reduction Program assistance to cover those costs.

 

 

Third, Ukraine asked for security assurances. The statement provided that, once Ukraine acceded to the Non-Proliferation Treaty as a non-nuclear weapon state, the United States, Russia, and Britain would undertake certain commitments for the independent Ukrainian state.

 

 

In December 1994, Clinton, Ukrainian President Leonid Kuchma (who succeeded Kravchuk), Yeltsin, and British Prime Minister John Major signed the Budapest memorandum, which committed the United States, Russia, and Britain "to respect the independence and sovereignty and the existing borders of Ukraine" and "to refrain from the threat or use of force against the territorial integrity or political independence of Ukraine." The agreement noted that "none of their [U.S., Russian, and British] weapons will ever be used against Ukraine except in self-defense or otherwise in accordance with the Charter of the United Nations."

The Budapest memorandum is a politically-binding agreement rather than a legally-binding treaty. Nevertheless, former Ukrainian officials in office at the time described it as crucial to Kiev's decision to give up nuclear arms.

 

 

When the four parties signed the memorandum in 1994, they agreed to meet should a nation feel that any of the commitments had been violated. For Ukraine, the violating country is, of course, Russia. And for the first time since the agreement was signed, Kiev has requested a meeting of the four nations.

 

 

Over the past week, Russian military forces have occupied Crimea, which Russia previously recognized as part of Ukraine. On Tuesday, March 4, Russian President Vladimir Putin denied that Russian forces have taken over the peninsula, asserting that "local militias" are manning checkpoints, blockading Ukrainian military bases and controlling Crimea's main points of entry. That claim defies credibility. Putin explained that the militias wore Russian-style combat fatigues because they could be purchased in army stores in post-Soviet states. (The reporters did not think to ask whether the Russian army jeeps and armored personnel carriers seen all around Crimea also could be purchased in those army stores.)

 

 

Russia has long based elements of the Black Sea Fleet and associated units in Crimea -- with Ukrainian agreement. Kiev has made no threats against those bases, and Ukrainian military forces on the peninsula have exercised great restraint. Moscow has no basis to claim self-defense and indeed has not invoked the right of self-defense. The Russian government, which normally insists that military action other than self-defense can be undertaken only with the approval of the U.N. Security Council, has not sought such approval. Instead, the Russian U.N. representative has been castigated by his counterparts for Russia's seizure of Crimea.

 

 

Given the violation of the Budapest memorandum, the Ukrainians invoked the commitment to consult. On Wednesday, March 5, U.S. Secretary of State John Kerry, British Foreign Minister William Hague and Acting Ukrainian Foreign Minister Andriy Deshchitsya met in Paris. Russian Foreign Minister Sergei Lavrov, although in Paris, chose not to attend.

 

 

Russian officials offered a novel defense for not carrying out the commitment to consult. They said that they had not signed the Budapest memorandum with the current government in Kiev. But the agreement is among the United States, Russia, Ukraine, and Britain -- not particular governments. Were this bizarre diplomatic logic applied more generally, states would have to again sign every agreement they have with another state when the latter changed its government.

 

 

The United States must live up to its Budapest commitments, if for no other reason than this is part of the price that Washington agreed to pay in 1994 to eliminate 1,900 strategic nuclear warheads and some 220 ICBMs and bombers that were designed to attack America. In the first instance, that means providing political support to Kiev and working with the International Monetary Fund and European Union on financial credits for Ukraine. Second, it means consulting with Kiev and the European Union to find a negotiating path to resolve the crisis. And third, it means coordinating with European and other countries to penalize Russia until it alters its behavior.

 

 

This is not just a question of living up to past U.S. commitments; it is a question of protecting the value of security assurances as leverage for resolving future proliferation challenges. It is possible, for example, that U.S. security assurances of some kind to Iran might play a role in finding a permanent settlement to the Iranian nuclear issue. But security assurances in the future will have little credibility unless the United States fulfills those that it undertook in Budapest.

 

 

SERGEI SUPINSKY/AFP/Getty Images

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

http://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:http://www.foreignpolicy.com/articles/2014/03/07/honoring_neither_the_letter_nor_the_law_ukrainian_nuclear_weapons 

Comments: 1054
#954   Yanira
      
References:


Play pokies online real money australia https://rentry.co/
5 November 2026 00:57
#953   Lorie
      
References:


Fast withdrawal neosurf casinos best neosurf online casinos australia 2026
4 November 2026 20:45
#952   Bell
      
References:


Free credit pokies payid real money no deposit
bonus https://schoolido.lu/
4 November 2026 18:28
#951   Bell
      
References:


Spin australia casino real money payid pokies australia real money
4 November 2026 18:08
#950   Malorie
      
References:


Seriöses Trustly Casino Trustly
Slots
4 November 2026 15:48
#949   Rory
      
References:


Wire transfer casino deposit australia quick wire transfer casino payouts
4 November 2026 14:32
#948   Rhonda
      
References:


Bank transfer mobile pokies australia wire transfer
casino promotions Australia
4 November 2026 12:33
#947   Kristian
      
References:


Neosurf casino bonus codes australia materialwiki.site
4 November 2026 12:15
#946   Arleen
      
This provides an alternative to depositing directly with a debit or
credit card. Among Neosurf online slots
australia neosurf
casinos in Australia, Boho Casino offers a combination of prepaid deposits,
casino games, cashback and loyalty-style rewards.
Its promotional structure also includes several deposit-based offers,
cashback and loyalty-style rewards.
4 November 2026 10:49
#945   Tristan
      
Skrill deposit casino bank wire pokies australia is fun and there
is no need to think about safety and scams.

Visa and Mastercard are among the most convenient withdrawal methods at online casinos in Australia, but they aren’t the quickest.
PayID serves as an intermediary, ensuring a smooth
and safe transaction.
4 November 2026 09:12
#944   Jamison
      
The above guide addresses the most crucial areas related to Neosurf casino payments.
Still, you must open an account and share your personal details to utilize it, essentially forfeiting
the voucher’s benefits discussed throughout this guide.
Nevertheless, you must not share the 10-digit Neosurf code with anyone
or you risk losing the entire value. Minimum deposits
– Neosurf is in line with the minimum payment limits of most online casinos, with a
minimum value of A$10 per deposit. That’s more than enough to try the 200+ online pokies and casino-style games featured at Uptown Pokies.
Uptown Pokies is the best A$10 Neosurf minimum deposit
casino in Australia.

References: https://forume.ch/t/how-to-use-neosurf-at-casino-australia-a-clear-guide/2029
4 November 2026 08:20
#943   Rochelle
      
References:


Neosurf real money online casino aus instant
withdrawal casino australia neosurf
4 November 2026 06:10
#942   Susanna
      
Es ist wichtig, sich daran zu erinnern, dass jedes Kasino, das Klarna akzeptiert, seine eigenen Bonusregeln hat
und verschiedene Boni unterschiedliche Wettanforderungen haben können. Auch
im Casino mit Klarna können Sie Echtgeldgewinne durch eine
reguläre Banküberweisung erhalten. Die Webanwendung lässt sich einfach via Browser App aufrufen und präsentiert
eine optimierte Nutzererfahrung sowie das uneingeschränkte Glücksspielangebot für Smartphones und Tablets.
Das Unternehmen hinter dem Bezahlanbieter lässt ebenfalls keinen Zweifel an der Vertrauenswürdigkeit von Klarna.
Es ist wichtig zu beachten, dass, wenn ein casino mit sofort bonus Klarna-Zahlungen anbietet, diese Zahlungsmethode in der Regel auch für den Erhalt des Willkommensbonus berechtigt.

Sollten Nutzer an einen Glücksspielanbieter geraten, der hier nicht zu finden ist aber dennoch Klarna als
Zahlungsmethode anbietet, sollte sichergestellt werden, dass der Anbieter diese
Kriterien einhält.
3 November 2026 10:09
#941   King
      
Der erste Schritt, der im Falle von Zahlungsproblemen unternommen werden muss, ist die Sicherstellung der Einhaltung der Anforderungen des Casinos in Bezug auf Boni und progressive Jackpots.

Doch gibt es seriöse Alternativen, die eine schnelle und zuverlässige Auszahlung garantieren. Wir haben auf dieser Seite einige Optionen in Online Casinos mit Sofortauszahlung
identifiziert.

References: sofortüberweisung casino
31 October 2026 12:47
#940   Karla
      
30 October 2026 18:12
#939   Bonita
      
https://jm-plancul.net/

This paragraph will help the internet visitors for creating new website or
even a weblog from start to end.

Also visit my blog; plan cul gratuit (https://jm-plancul.net/)
30 October 2026 17:10
#938   Lila
      
References:


Australian pokies bank transfer deposit online pokies accepting
bank transfer australia
30 October 2026 16:26
#937   Priscilla
      
References:


New payid pokies australia pad.multiplace.org
30 October 2026 11:06
#936   Wallace
      
References:


Top rated payid pokies 5 dollar deposit pokies
payid
30 October 2026 08:21
#935   Kassandra
      
References:


Desktop payid pokies $5 payid pokies australia
30 October 2026 06:24
Add Comments

Name:*
E-Mail:
  Geo Keyboard  
 

Dear reader, guardian.ge welcomes your comments. Please express your views on topic and be respectful of others.

bold italic underline strike | align left centered align right | Ensert smilies insert linkInsert protected URL Choice the color | hidden text insert quote Convert selected text from transliteration to Cyrillic alphabet Insert spoiler

Code: *


Back1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 ... 53Next